-----------

Your question about reports claiming COVID-19 was “already endemic to India” in early 2021, while treated as a pandemic elsewhere, is a sharp observation that ties into your broader inquiry about whether India could be the origin of SARS-CoV-2, your concerns about availability bias, and the validity of the “ancestral strain” model. The claim of endemicity in India likely stems from specific studies or statements made during India’s devastating second wave (driven by the Delta variant), and the discrepancy in terminology reflects differences in context, data interpretation, and public health framing rather than evidence that SARS-CoV-2 originated in India or was uniquely entrenched there. Let’s break this down, addressing the reported claim, why India’s situation was described differently, and how this relates to the origin debate.What Does “Endemic” Mean in This Context?Endemic: A disease is considered endemic when it is consistently present in a population or region at a stable, predictable level, often with seasonal or localized patterns (e.g., flu in many countries). This contrasts with a pandemic, where a novel pathogen spreads rapidly across regions with little population immunity, causing widespread outbreaks.

Early 2021 Context in India: By early 2021, India was experiencing a massive second wave, driven by the Delta variant (B.1.617.2, first detected in India in late 2020). Reports of COVID-19 being “endemic” in India likely emerged from studies or statements suggesting the virus was becoming a persistent, widespread presence in the population, not that it originated there or was no longer a public health crisis.

Source of the “Endemic in India” ClaimThe claim that COVID-19 was “already endemic to India” in early 2021 likely refers to specific studies or media reports during India’s second wave (March-May 2021). For example:Seroprevalence Studies: Studies by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) in 2020-2021 showed high antibody prevalence in urban areas (e.g., 50-60% in Delhi and Mumbai by mid-2021), suggesting widespread exposure. Some researchers interpreted this as the virus transitioning toward endemicity, meaning it was circulating broadly and might persist at a baseline level, especially with variants like Delta.

Public Health Statements: In early 2021, some Indian health officials (e.g., ICMR scientists) speculated that COVID-19 was becoming “endemic” in parts of India due to high case numbers, uneven vaccination rollout, and the Delta wave’s scale. For instance, a February 2021 ICMR statement suggested India might be approaching endemicity in high-transmission areas, though this was not a claim of origin or that the virus was no longer a crisis.

Media Misinterpretation: Media outlets sometimes amplified these statements, framing COVID-19 as “endemic” in India to contrast with its earlier pandemic status, leading to confusion. This was less about scientific consensus and more about local observations of sustained transmission.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5748318&forum_id=2...id#49087293)