Over dissent, HELD: Ariz. Dept. of Ag. may approve identical cattle brands.
| Low-t church | 08/09/16 | | Low-t church | 08/09/16 | | Exhilarant Irate Tattoo | 08/09/16 | | Low-t church | 08/09/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 08/10/16 | | Low-t church | 02/27/17 | | Twisted opaque field | 06/21/17 | | Low-t church | 08/10/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 08/10/16 | | pea-brained haunted graveyard | 08/10/16 | | citrine doobsian legend stead | 08/10/16 | | Low-t church | 08/10/16 | | Crystalline dilemma | 08/04/17 | | Fantasy-prone 180 sneaky criminal laser beams | 08/10/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 08/10/16 | | Indecent coldplay fan | 09/12/16 | | Fantasy-prone 180 sneaky criminal laser beams | 08/10/16 | | Low-t church | 08/10/16 | | sooty concupiscible property dopamine | 08/11/16 | | twinkling forum | 10/18/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 08/10/16 | | Low-t church | 08/11/16 | | wild love of her life hospital | 12/24/23 | | Low-t church | 08/11/16 | | spectacular crackhouse water buffalo | 08/11/16 | | White Slimy Site | 09/13/16 | | Bateful Insanely Creepy Striped Hyena Senate | 08/11/16 | | Low-t church | 03/10/17 | | bespoke pontificating step-uncle's house crotch | 08/11/16 | | Low-t church | 08/11/16 | | Low-t church | 08/12/16 | | Effete heaven | 03/06/17 | | Low-t church | 09/12/16 | | sooty concupiscible property dopamine | 09/12/16 | | pea-brained haunted graveyard | 09/13/16 | | Low-t church | 09/13/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 09/12/16 | | cerebral cyan hell | 09/12/16 | | apoplectic address | 09/12/16 | | violent immigrant background story | 09/13/16 | | Low-t church | 02/27/17 | | cerebral cyan hell | 09/12/16 | | Low-t church | 09/13/16 | | Soul-stirring Filthy Telephone Dingle Berry | 09/12/16 | | fragrant stage masturbator | 09/13/16 | | Low-t church | 09/13/16 | | Indecent coldplay fan | 09/13/16 | | White Slimy Site | 09/13/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 10/07/16 | | Low-t church | 10/07/16 | | Low-t church | 10/17/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 10/17/16 | | Razzle Lime Office | 10/18/16 | | Bipolar antidepressant drug | 03/06/17 | | Low-t church | 11/28/16 | | french bawdyhouse | 11/28/16 | | Twisted opaque field | 12/16/16 | | Low-t church | 02/27/17 | | french bawdyhouse | 02/27/17 | | Low-t church | 02/27/17 | | french bawdyhouse | 02/27/17 | | Low-t church | 03/06/17 | | french bawdyhouse | 03/06/17 | | Boyish Turquoise Dysfunction Organic Girlfriend | 03/06/17 | | bearded center | 03/06/17 | | lake black woman kitty cat | 03/06/17 | | Low-t church | 03/08/17 | | Low-t church | 03/10/17 | | Boyish Turquoise Dysfunction Organic Girlfriend | 03/10/17 | | Heady mad cow disease really tough guy | 03/10/17 | | Boyish Turquoise Dysfunction Organic Girlfriend | 03/10/17 | | Low-t church | 03/10/17 | | Low-t church | 05/24/17 | | Low-t church | 06/02/17 | | offensive principal's office | 06/02/17 | | Hilarious Zombie-like Nursing Home | 06/02/17 | | Low-t church | 06/02/17 | | Hilarious Zombie-like Nursing Home | 06/02/17 | | Effete heaven | 06/03/17 | | Low-t church | 06/21/17 | | Twisted opaque field | 06/21/17 | | Low-t church | 07/31/17 | | Big Submissive Knife | 07/31/17 | | Low-t church | 08/03/17 | | Low-t church | 08/03/17 | | french bawdyhouse | 08/03/17 | | lake black woman kitty cat | 08/03/17 | | Low-t church | 08/03/17 | | Twisted opaque field | 02/13/18 | | Indecent coldplay fan | 06/03/22 | | wild love of her life hospital | 12/24/23 | | Low-t church | 08/04/17 | | Drunken roommate point | 02/13/18 | | bespoke pontificating step-uncle's house crotch | 02/13/18 | | Twisted opaque field | 02/13/18 | | Low-t church | 06/03/22 | | Low-t church | 02/05/24 | | Cream abode | 06/03/22 | | jet-lagged casino | 07/11/22 | | jet-lagged casino | 12/24/23 | | swashbuckling startled scourge upon the earth pistol | 12/24/23 | | wild love of her life hospital | 12/24/23 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: August 9th, 2016 3:53 PM Author: Low-t church
Stambaugh v. Butler, No. 1 CA-CV 14-0817 (Ariz. Ct. App. Aug 9, 2016)
http://www.azcourts.gov/Portals/0/OpinionFiles/Div1/2016/CV14-0817.pdf
FACTS: Dude who has a bar seven (-7) cattle brand placed on the left rib wants to take his beasts from California to Arizona. He asks the Arizona Department of Agriculture for permission. Another dude in Arizona with a bar seven cattle brand placed on the left hip objects, NO FUCKING WAY; THAT'S MINE. And the statute says you can't register two identical designs.
ISSUE: Does the law allow identical brands on different parts of the cow?
HELD: Yes. Despite statutory language providing that "[n]o two brands of the same design or figure shall be adopted or recorded," the Arizona Department of Agriculture may approve identical brands if the brands are registered to different locations on the animal.
DISSENT: You fools. The prohibition on having the same DESIGN is completely separate from the statutory language you rely on concerning the LOCATION the design is placed.
DEEP ANALYSIS: Dissents are rare in Arizona appellate cases, and they're usually right when a judge goes to the effort of writing one. Here, the majority bared its unscholarly motives when it was, like, "Yeah, but if we don't allow the same brand in different places, it might invalidate other brands, and that's bad." The California cattledood should have been told to come up with a different brand.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31144562)
|
Date: August 9th, 2016 3:55 PM Author: Low-t church
Don't say I never do anything for you.
This is cutting edge shit.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31144575) |
|
Date: August 9th, 2016 4:15 PM Author: Low-t church
Beyond the pale.
Perhaps we should offer our services to petition for supreme court review.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31144712)
|
Date: August 10th, 2016 7:04 AM Author: Fantasy-prone 180 sneaky criminal laser beams
Majority: "Who gives a shit about the exact wording of the law as long as the function of telling the brands apart is served?"
Minority: "WTF? This is directly contradictory to the law."
tbf,the majority opinion seems more efficient in this case but represents quite a transfer of power to the court
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31150026) |
|
Date: August 10th, 2016 7:17 PM Author: Low-t church
JUSTICE FOR THE STAMBAUGH COWS!
Look at this jibberish:
"The ambiguity exists by virtue of the language of A.R.S. § 3-1261 and related statutes, read in context with each other. Accordingly, we must look, inter alia, to the Department’s longstanding construction of the statutes. *****To do otherwise might render invalid hundreds of brands the Department accepted for recording over the past several decades based on their owners’ promises to apply the brands in different locations than prior similar recorded brands were to be applied.***** "
What do the consequences of "do[ing] otherwise" have to do with the interpretive task at hand?
Nothing. That's what.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31154793)
|
|
Date: August 11th, 2016 12:19 AM Author: sooty concupiscible property dopamine
also seems like appellate court fact-finding
and results driven reasoning
and an impermissible delegation of power to agency that exceeds plain statutory text
i mean wtf. wtf.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31156945) |
|
Date: August 12th, 2016 5:12 PM Author: Low-t church
http://bit.ly/2aRjSF7
Motions for reconsideration due by August 24, 2016.
Petitions for supreme court review due by September 8, 2016.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31170666) |
Date: September 12th, 2016 6:30 PM Author: Low-t church
Petition for review filed with Arizona Supreme Court.
http://bit.ly/2cms4Ke
May justice be done.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31392299) |
Date: September 13th, 2016 7:44 PM Author: Indecent coldplay fan
this
is why we got into law
fuck this bullshit. this pisses me off so much.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31400584) |
|
Date: October 7th, 2016 6:49 PM Author: Low-t church
A petition for review was filed, but the supreme court only grants around 3.9% of petitions in civil cases, which is usually a bit under 20 cases per year. It's a long shot.
Right now, it's taking about four months for the supreme court to consider petitions for review, and then it takes a while for them to get around to issuing the order to grant or deny.
The state got an extension until October 28 to file its response to the petition. So I'd guess that the petition will be decided around April.
Here's the supreme court's docket: http://apps.supremecourt.az.gov/aacc/appella/ASC/CV/CV160217.PDF
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#31582282) |
Date: February 27th, 2017 4:47 PM Author: Low-t church
Petition for review GRANTED against all odds.
http://i.xomf.com/gspkr.png
May there be justice for Stambaugh's cows!
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#32713763) |
Date: March 8th, 2017 12:33 PM Author: Low-t church
Oral argument video available here:
https://www.azcourts.gov/AZ-Supreme-Court/Live-Archived-Video
I haven't watched it yet to see whether things are looking good for the Stambaugh cows, but I did notice that I had to turn off some of my ad blocking to get the video to load correctly.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#32782045) |
|
Date: March 10th, 2017 1:12 AM Author: Low-t church
Thoughts on oral argument.
(1) The state's attorney was having a rough time, but he shut up one of the justices when the justice was, like, "Have you even seen branding?" and the lawyers was, like, "Motherfucker, I grew up on a ranch. I've done it. It's easy."
38:44 - context
39:09 - rancher-lawyer revealed
(2) On whole, I think things went better for Stambaugh's cows. May justice be done.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#32795775) |
Date: March 10th, 2017 12:43 PM Author: Low-t church
For those following along, the caption is now Stambaugh v. Killian.
Be sure to update your Westlaw and Lexis alerts.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#32797775) |
Date: August 3rd, 2017 1:31 PM Author: Low-t church Subject: JUSTICE FOR THE STAMBAUGH CATTLE!
http://www.azcourts.gov/Portals/0/OpinionFiles/Supreme/2017/CV160217PR.pdf
¶1 Arizona Revised Statute § 3-1261(B) provides that no two brands of the same design or figure shall be adopted or recorded. Nonetheless, the Arizona Department of Agriculture (“Department”) allowed Eureka Springs to record a “bar seven” brand (—7), even though it was identical to a previously recorded brand owned by David Stambaugh, because it was placed on a different location on the animals. We hold that the plain language of the statute precludes the Department from recording “two brands of the same design or figure” regardless of their location.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#33910822) |
|
Date: June 3rd, 2022 8:28 PM Author: Indecent coldplay fan
this case has tortured me for almost six years and i didn't know this outcome
to be fair, it only felt like 2, maybe 3 years ago, but still
allahu akbar and God bless america!
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3316554&forum_id=2#44622573)
|
|
|