NYT op-ed by Harvard prof argues for human biodiversity
| saffron bawdyhouse | 03/23/18 | | saffron bawdyhouse | 03/23/18 | | Big immigrant | 03/23/18 | | Salmon Razzmatazz Station New Version | 03/23/18 | | Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home | 03/23/18 | | Dead hilarious hall | 03/23/18 | | self-centered alpha | 03/28/18 | | domesticated rusted corner tank | 03/23/18 | | Opaque dashing house | 03/23/18 | | turquoise mediation | 03/23/18 | | carnelian church | 03/24/18 | | Talking Cocky Gas Station Kitty Cat | 03/23/18 | | turquoise mediation | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | curious dull national wagecucks | 03/23/18 | | Insane puppy locus | 03/23/18 | | swashbuckling arrogant kitty feces | 03/23/18 | | orange disturbing dilemma | 03/23/18 | | chrome legend legal warrant | 03/23/18 | | Supple yellow pervert ticket booth | 03/23/18 | | canary sadistic tattoo stead | 03/23/18 | | Henna orchestra pit | 03/23/18 | | lilac heady field mood | 03/28/18 | | Vermilion thirsty hairy legs marketing idea | 03/23/18 | | Vivacious idiot heaven | 03/24/18 | | know-it-all theatre | 03/23/18 | | chrome legend legal warrant | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | burgundy reading party regret | 03/24/18 | | Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home | 03/23/18 | | Wild Stimulating Water Buffalo Fat Ankles | 03/23/18 | | Bright hairraiser telephone meetinghouse | 03/23/18 | | canary sadistic tattoo stead | 03/23/18 | | Dead hilarious hall | 03/23/18 | | lilac heady field mood | 03/28/18 | | know-it-all theatre | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | self-centered alpha | 03/23/18 | | mewling silver senate therapy | 03/24/18 | | Vivacious idiot heaven | 03/24/18 | | Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home | 03/23/18 | | canary sadistic tattoo stead | 03/23/18 | | dun cuckold codepig | 03/23/18 | | Henna orchestra pit | 03/23/18 | | Dead hilarious hall | 03/23/18 | | canary sadistic tattoo stead | 03/23/18 | | Abusive library dog poop | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | Abusive library dog poop | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | carmine confused macaca pozpig | 03/23/18 | | angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann | 03/23/18 | | carmine confused macaca pozpig | 03/23/18 | | effete business firm | 03/23/18 | | Slap-happy hot forum boistinker | 03/24/18 | | effete business firm | 03/23/18 | | Histrionic Gay Blood Rage | 03/23/18 | | effete business firm | 03/23/18 | | Boyish bistre parlor ladyboy | 03/24/18 | | Lascivious gaped elastic band | 03/23/18 | | Floppy Misanthropic Whorehouse French Chef | 03/24/18 | | orange disturbing dilemma | 03/24/18 | | Aphrodisiac area | 03/28/18 | | Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home | 03/28/18 | | Histrionic Gay Blood Rage | 03/28/18 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: March 23rd, 2018 5:48 PM Author: saffron bawdyhouse
"I am worried that well-meaning people who deny the possibility of substantial biological differences among human populations are digging themselves into an indefensible position, one that will not survive the onslaught of science."
https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/03/23/opinion/sunday/genetics-race.html
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35672932)
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 5:57 PM Author: angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann
Razib was posting this earlier.
Still nothing from Sailer on it.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673044)
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:01 PM Author: Insane puppy locus
some dumbs in comments
Duncan Osborne
NYC, NY4h ago
Times Pick
Spare me the concerned scientist posture.
If you are a researcher who believes that genetics predicts performance on an IQ test, you also have to concede that the differences in performance on those tests between groups has changed over time with the lowest performing groups showing improvement and performance among all groups improving over time. This disproves the thesis that intelligence, whatever that is, is genetic and shows that environment most certainly plays a role.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673083) |
|
Date: March 24th, 2018 7:34 AM Author: Vivacious idiot heaven
Holy shit - but unfortunately many non-retarded libs I've talked to have this kind of thinking.
Their minds are so warped by identity politics and the great big boogeyman of racism - that their default argument in these discussion is against a strawman who thinks it's 100% genetic determinism. The fact that the gaps in group-level outcomes/measurements have changed over time is 100% expected.
There's gene-environment interactions, we never said environment contributes 0% you dimwitted delusional freaks.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35676382) |
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:32 PM Author: angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann
Don't forget Abbos.
Abbos are significantly dumber than even straight up subsuharan Africans.
Even the smartest 1/3rd of them are too dumb to hold down the most menial of jobs. No matter how hard Austrailia tries.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673364) |
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:13 PM Author: Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home
this is a NYT pick. lmao
steve
nyc9h ago
Times Pick
This is an important discussion to have and Reich approaches it with appropriate caution. However, he may commit a common philosophical and scientific error.
In his explication of cognition or intelligence, he cites both intelligence tests and years of education. What he does not acknowledge is that both of these measures, which he admits are imperfect, are measures of those things that a controlling population has deemed of value. While I'm not a slavish devotee of theories of multiple intelligence, it is clear from my work as an educator, that many people are brilliant and perceptive in ways that are not measured by standard assessments or valued in the selection process that is a gateway to continuing education.
The self-fulfilling prophetic issue is that a set of "intelligences" and a set of social traits have been ordained as the default standard, thereby perpetuating the perceived value of those humans who determined the standard and possess those particular traits.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673178) |
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:14 PM Author: Fuchsia Wonderful Nursing Home
another NYT pick that also proudly claims WE WUZ KANGZ
John Graubard
NYC10h ago
Times Pick
The problem is not that humans differ in many ways, or that these differences are caused by our genetic background. It is not either that these variations tend to be grouped by place of origin, or that these variations do lead to differing abilities.
The problem is that we instinctively categorize people into all-or-nothing groups, and then treat these groups as the only relevant factor. Then, we impose tribalism to define "our" group as superior to the rest. That leads to such absurd results as portraying the ancient Egyptians as white (they were black) or the Chinese as backwards (in 1400 they were the most powerful and advanced country).
Indeed, modern genetic research demonstrates that all non-Africans contain Neanderthal genes. So, if you belong to that group, remember that you, and not they, are descendents of what we have put down as the cavemen.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673193) |
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:16 PM Author: dun cuckold codepig
Larry
Upstate NY4h ago
There was no effort to address the interaction between genes and environment in Reich's article. It sounds like the reified genetics of the 1950s, not considering the role of epigenetics in shaping the reality of genetic expression. Plus, he is completely naive to the ways articles such as this can be misused for political reasons.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673209) |
Date: March 23rd, 2018 6:35 PM Author: Abusive library dog poop
There is no genetic basis for race, but there are a lot of phenotypes that correlate depending on where you anscestors came from.
Good news - we can test to see if you have the smart gene independent of what gene you have for skin color and you can prove the haters wrong.
Bad news - we can test to confirm what we suspect, that *you* do not have the smart gene.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35673389) |
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 8:50 PM Author: angry concupiscible famous landscape painting boltzmann
Wrong way to look at race. A Race is just an extended family that tends to share certain phenotypes in certain frequencies because of shares common ancestors increasing/decreasing the likihood of those genes.
Saying race is not a valid concept is absolutely absurd and requires language games.
It's equally as absurd as saying family is not a valid concept.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35674414) |
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 9:14 PM Author: carmine confused macaca pozpig
As I stated, race is a valid concept. Also, the more finely we distinguish, the more closely the sub-categories will correlate to actual genes.
Edit: But as Earl was pointing out, the most easily visible phenotypes that people often use to classify race are not necessarily the most closely correlated to genetic similarity.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35674622)
|
|
Date: March 23rd, 2018 8:59 PM Author: effete business firm
Just try to plot races as dots on a graph and see how silly that objection is.
Sure, if East Africans are at (5,5) and West Africans are at (5,0) while Europeans are at (0,0), they're as far apart from each other as Europeans are from West Africans, but the cluster "African" still gives you information about where they are.
Genetics may be far more dimensional than that, but it is still entirely possible that some traits cluster by 'race' even if there is significant variation within a race.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35674520) |
Date: March 24th, 2018 11:34 AM Author: Floppy Misanthropic Whorehouse French Chef
180
i predict that he's going to be crucified for exactly the same reason watson, wade, jensen were even though he does the ritualistic shaming of watson and wade to try to separate himself from them.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3927126&forum_id=2#35677046) |
|
|