What gets me every single time is how tight those virgin holes are. That first push inside a never-fucked ass is like nothing else. It clamps down around your cock like a hot, trembling fist, fighting every thick inch at first before it starts to give. They gasp and shake and try to take it like good boys, and then something clicks. The resistance melts and that hole starts to open up and suck you in, learning what it was made for. By the time I’m balls-deep they are already pushing back, begging without words, turning into the kind of needy, obedient cumdumpster that only a real first-timer can become.

This twink was 20 years old. Lean, maybe five-nine, smooth pale skin that flushed easy, messy dark hair that fell into his eyes, and these wide, nervous brown eyes that kept flicking up to my face and then away again. He had that fresh, clean college-kid look. Soft lips. A shy smile when he first walked in. I could tell he had spent a long time getting ready, probably shaved everywhere, probably changed his outfit twice.

We moved to the bedroom without saying much. I took his shirt off first. Ran my hands over that smooth chest and flat stomach. He shivered when I undid his jeans and pushed them down. No underwear. His cock was already hard, leaking a little at the tip. I stroked him slow while I kissed his neck and told him how good he was going to feel once I was inside him, once I was stretching that virgin hole and breeding him full.

I got him on his back on the bed, legs spread wide, knees pulled up toward his chest. He looked so fucking vulnerable like that, spread open on my sheets, his lean soccer-player body flushed pink from his chest all the way up to his cheeks. Those wide brown eyes were huge, darting nervously between my face and my cock, pupils blown wide.

Lingered him then took him raw.When I came I stayed buried deep and pumped every drop inside him. He came right after without me touching his cock at all.

(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=5880722&forum_id=2E#49985850)